It seems as if, judging by recent comments and questions received, that my stance on the construction projects at Cedar Beach has not been stated clearly enough. Today, I will share with you my opinion on those projects, one by one, so that you know exactly where I am coming from.
1. Rose Garden and Old Fashioned Garden PathwaysI love this project. I love what has been done. The day that the stone was installed I was a little apprehensive about its appearance given that it was raised a few inches from the ground. That issue has since been remedied and the ground has been entirely evened out. I commend all who labored in the summer heat to get the job done. It looks great.
2. Riparian Buffer Installation
I care more about this than anything else. I am 100% behind this and I was proud to be able to spend a couple of days at Cedar Beach helping plant the buffer. When spring returns you can expect to see a chronicled documentation on the growth of these plants and the development of this incredibly necessary project.
3. The PlaygroundI realize what a hot button subject this is for people but for me, a glance at the eroded banks of Cedar Creek and the bared roots of Willow trees puts this project in perspective. The environmental restoration of Cedar Beach should be the absolute priority of any construction project in the park. I believe that Muhlenberg Lake should have been addressed and fixed before the playground. Again, I do not oppose it. I question what “phase” of construction it should be involved in. It will undoubtedly serve as a gateway into a park that will hopefully offer a new generation an invaluable experience, which will be, a first real connection with nature.
4. Reflecting Pond Restoration and Path PavingCleaning up the ponds that were obviously becoming victims of eutrophication is a no-brainer. It absolutely should have been done, and I am glad it has been done. There is still work needed to be finished around the large pond and as I posted on here two weeks ago, Greg Weitzel has pledged that the work will be done.
I am completely, 100%, against paving the paths that have been paved. It does not benefit runners who are the most frequent path users. The environmental impact is negative and as they paved the paths they destroyed a large section of newly planted natural vegetation that was to serve as one of the most beautiful areas of flora in Cedar Beach. Dropping asphalt onto that was reprehensible and while I realize the paving is still a work in process, it currently looks poor and is negatively contrasting the good work done in the Gardens.
5. Future ProjectsAt this moment, I am not entirely sure what is going to be done when, so I am going to refrain from speculative commentary until I know what is next. I will say that I am against creating extraneous paths that will remove more vegetation in a park area that barely has any to begin with. It would also give me great satisfaction to see the projects that are being done now completed and immediate plans put forward to fix Jordan Park, Trout Creek Parkway and Canal Park.
It is my belief, and I think I have made this rather apparent, that those three parks should be priority and until they are, we are doing a disservice to our parks system.
I am not entirely for or against the project at Cedar Beach and I think it would be silly if I said I felt one of those two ways. This is not a black and white generalization kind of situation and to think that it is, is nonsensical. Unfortunately, I cannot say that I am 100% behind everything because I would love to be. That would mean of course, that the vision I would have for the parks was being implemented and I can easily be 100% certain that my plan would go over like a fart in church. Overall, I think what is being done is good. There are some things that could/should have been done differently, but no one/nothing is perfect.
So, there you have it. Andrew Kleiner likes the pathways in the Gardens. Andrew Kleiner has Buffer madness. Andrew Kleiner is supporting the playground because he can see the good that will come from it rather than dwell on speculative negative possibilities. Andrew Kleiner is militantly opposed to the recent pave job and extraneous path creation. Andrew Kleiner believes that there are more dire environmental circumstances at Muhlenberg Lake, Jordan Park, Canal Park and Trout Creek Parkway that should be addressed immediately and before any further development at Cedar Beach.Thanks for reading, it is after all, just one man's opinion.
Labels: Cedar Beach Parkway, Rose Garden